Unspeakable Speech: 2018

What happened across America last week is unspeakable. But these unspeakable acts of violence have a long history in speech itself. The bombs mailed from Florida did not come out of a speechless void. Nor did Saturday’s attack on Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh.

Tree of Life

Tree of Life*Or L’Simcha Congregation

If ever the Hebrew proverb was true that those with a pure heart and gracious speech will have the king for their friend (Book of Proverbs 22:11), it is true no longer in 2018. The massacre of Jewish worshipers on Shabbat does not come out of a vacuum. Hate speech once uttered cannot be put back. It has a murderous history we dare not forget, and casts a long dark shadow into the future we dare not abide.

Words are powerful. Speech is powerful. Silence is powerful. Acquiescence is powerful. When the words come from the President of the United States — or when they do not come, or when they come only in part — they contribute to the worst in us. They cast their shadow far into the American future. White nationalism/Christian nationalism is the forbidden fruit of the tree from which we must not eat. It is not the fruit of the Tree of Life (Genesis 3). It is the fruit of the tree of death.

As the city officials and Jewish leaders in Pittsburgh prepare for the President’s controversial visit the day they begin burying their loved ones, we offer a rabbi’s voice to help the rest of us understand.

Reb Arthur WaskowHealing for the Stricken Community,
for the Shaken Jewish People,
and for Our Deeply Wounded Country

Dear friends,

There are many disastrous levels to the murderous massacre at Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh.

There is the immediate personal disaster of eleven lives destroyed, others wounded, families and friends bereft, a neighborhood traumatized.  To all these, The Shalom Center as a body and I individually send blessings of swift refuah (healing) for the wounded,  deep respect and grief for the dead, and loving care for those bereaved.

There is the broader disaster of shock to the American Jewish community, until now so profoundly joyful to have found full acceptance in America these last several generations, after millennia of persecution elsewhere and elsewhen.
Some of us took from that safety acceptance in becoming affluent, even wealthy, even powerful. Some of us took from that safety acceptance in becoming social critics, progressives, even radicals.

Less comfort as critics than as powerful, of course – but comfortable that all the clauses of the First Amendment affirmed our worth as Jews, as sacred fringes on conventional assumptions, as challengers who could wrestle not only with God (as our name “Yisrael” describes us) but with the rigidified habits of ourselves and others.

And even worse, the broader disaster of facing an American government that our immigrant forebears who came here for freedom’s sake could not have fathomed:

A government honeycombed with white supremacism, moving into neofascism,  calling forth from the shadows into boastful visibility those who concoct bombs to enforce their racism, who can openly revel in their contempt for women, who can turn hatred of foreigners into willingness to rip babies from their mothers’ breasts,  who can turn their greed for hyperwealth into willingness to torch the Earth that is our common home, our only home  — and who can turn their latent anti-Semitism into mass murder.

How do we respond to these layered levels of disaster?

-Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Shalom Center, Philadelphia, PA

Following a week of unspeakable violence, Rabbi Waskow’s question addresses all of us. Today in Pittsburgh is a day to keep silence before a Word of comfort and direction deeper than our own. Tomorrow and November 6 is time for all of us to speak.

  • Gordon C. Stewart, Chaska, MN, October 30, 2018

6 thoughts on “Unspeakable Speech: 2018

  1. Just no words, Gordon. Sometimes I think of this as a kind of plague. About 40% of Americans have been stricken, it seems. I don’t know how many would have succumbed without the main source, 45, with devastating help from **far too many** Republicans.

    It becomes nearly impossible to love all persons because each was made in the image of God. Where, *where* is the image of God in 45? Was he born with the image? Is it still there? Did someone tell him that that was no way to make money, or did he discover that on his own and consciously, on purpose, jettison it, or try to? Is it still there? and must we try to love him? That is a shattering thought. And the same question applies to a lot of other horrible Republicans, some of whom are, if anything, worse than 45 in the grief they are causing.


    • No words, Carolyn. But we can still sing the great hymns and anthems of thanksgiving and resistance.

      This morning — All Saints Day –I went back to Bonhoeffer. We remember him for his courage and resistance to the Nazism, but there are other ways he speaks in relation to your questions.

      “Judging others makes us blind, whereas love is illuminating. By judging others we blind ourselves to our own evil and to the grace which others are just as entitled to as we are.”

      “Nothing that we despise in other men is inherently absent from ourselves. We must learn to regard people less in the light of what they do or don’t do, and more in light of what they suffer.”

      I confess. OUCH! How does one do both?

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Gordon, THe people of the United States have been told what Trump was about and what he wanted to do. We have seen the darkness of his soul the words of his bigoted mouth. I wrote this morning a visit that Rachel and I made May, 1999.

    Spring of 1999 Rachel and I toured Dachau. Two things:One was a Newspaper published in Munich announcing the opening of this Concentration Camps was posted on the reception area of the Camp.
    It was not a secret held from the German people. It was announced. Dachau was to held Jews, Polish intellectuals, gays and Lesbians, gypsies. All the others scapegoated by Hitler as the source of “German problems.”
    The people were told. It was not invisible.

    We too have been told. Non-whites who commit acts of violence are terrorists, rapist, not “good people.” The Charlottesville hate crimes, the Trump loving Bomber, the Slaughter on Squirrel Hill or the execution in the Louisville Kroger…… mental health……


    • Jim, It gives little comfort to know there are two old classmates out there in Maryland who also look through the same or similar eyes, but I’ll take whatever encouragement you send. I scratch my head. It’s so obvious. But then I remember Zuurdeeg, Koyama, Stringfellow, Tillich, Barth, Buber, James Allison, Jim Cone, Bill Moyers, and William Barber, and I sort of “get” it. But no one in my experience got to the bottom of it more clearly than Zuurdeeg.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s