McCutcheon and Free Speech

My country ‘tis of thee,
Sweet land of baronry,
Of thee I sing.

Land where my fathers died,
Land of the pilgrim’s pride,
On every mountainside,
Let freedom ring!

Tuesday’s U.S. Supreme Court decision for McCutcheon in McCutcheon et. al. v. Federal Election Commission makes very clear the view of the Court that is remaking America.

Freedom of speech is protected; it’s just that a few of us have a whole lot more of it than the rest of us. We all are “equally” protected by the Constitution no matter how unequal we are economically.

Most of us understand that money is not speech. Money is purchasing power. Money comes from our pockets; speech comes from our mouths. Those who represent us in Congress and in state legislatures do not represent us so long as their campaigns are funded by the “free speech” that comes from the pockets of the robber barons.

The sweet land of liberty is the land of barony.

“My country ’twas of thee.”

Only the most sweeping legislation to remove this unequal purchasing power from the electoral process can restore what we thought we had. But even if the miracle were to occur, this 5-4 Court will strike it down on the basis of its skewed interpretation of the First Amendment right to free speech.

My inbox is stacked up with funding solicitations. Delete. Delete. Delete. Delete. It depresses me. I don’t have the money, and, even if I had more, I would still have the sense that I would be throwing money into the wind. So I write. I speak. I throw into the wind words and sentences and paragraphs believing that ultimately the Wind is with us, the people. It’s my way of praying for the miracle that will give us back our country. I use what little free speech the Court has protected to effect the day when we will sing “America” that way it should be sung.

In the meantime I gain courage from the joyful spirit of the late Pete Seeger. I imagine Pete standing with his banjo outside the U.S. Supreme Court singing “God’s counting on me; God’s counting on you.”

8 thoughts on “McCutcheon and Free Speech

  1. The last line might be, “Let money ring.” I keep wondering when one or more of the “powers,” executive, legislative, or judicial, will finally do something so outrageous that average conservative citizens have the blinders dropped from their eyes, and they see what is really happening to them, and to us.

    Like

    • Carolyn, It’ll take more than an earthquake, I’m afraid. But, as Karin commented, this decision has upset people in both major parties. That’s a hopeful sign. I’ll take a small sign anywhere I can get it.

      Like

  2. Equality and equal protection under the law doesn’t seem as protected or equal today. I have no thumb to put on the scale… This ruling seems like a negative Poll Tax…..

    Like

    • It seems so obvious. I’ve backed away from posts that repeat the same old stuff and that might contribute to the onslaught of junk, but I had to stick my foot out on this one.

      Peace,
      Jim

      Like

Leave a reply to fromsandyknob Cancel reply